Randomized Trial of Vaginal Self Sampling for Human Papillomavirus (HPV)

Pap smear screening for cervical cancer precursors has substantially reduced the incidence of invasive cervical cancer in Canada. While regular Pap screening can give up to 90% protection against cervical cancer, about 30% of Canadian women do not participate in regular screening.

Pap screening in Ontario is opportunistic. There are women who have family doctors and regularly present for other medical issues at their physician's office but forego Pap smear testing.

Numerous studies have shown that women are able to self collect vaginal samples, and that these samples can be tested for the presence of oncogenic human papillomavirus. A recent meta-analysis showed that HPV testing through physician collected samples had a sensitivity of 80%-90% for detection of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) 2 or worse, and a specificity of 86%-95%. In comparison, a meta-analysis of self collected vaginal samples tested for HPV showed a sensitivity of 74% and a specificity of 88%.

Studies have reported that women find self collection acceptable. However, we have found that many women are more comfortable if a health care professional is available to help if needed, and so this option should be provided for self-testing.

We are proposing a randomized controlled trial to see whether (a) the offer of a vaginal self collection kit together with a second reminder for Pap testing will increase cervical screening participation amongst "never-screened" and "hard to reach" women, as compared to (b) a second reminder letter alone.

• offer of vaginal self collection (Device), also known as flocked swab (Copan Diagnostics Inc.): Women assigned to the intervention group will be offered the opportunity to self collect a vaginal specimen for HPV testing. They will be sent a letter explaining that a study of self testing is being performed, and will invite her to participate in this study. The letter will state that, if the patient prefers, she can perform a vaginal self-test in addition to, or instead of Pap smear testing. Patients are told that they have the option of completing the self-test on their own or in their physician's office with the help of their physician or practice staff. The letter will be accompanied by a self collection kit consisting of: a swab and test tube, pamphlet (with written instructions and diagram outlining procedure), instructional DVD and return envelope.
• 2nd reminder letter for Pap testing (Other), also known as reminder letter: Women in both groups will receive a letter informing them that they are due for cervical screening. This is a standard letter, and is signed by the patient's individual family physicians. It will advise the patient that this is the second reminder letter that she is due for cervical cancer screening, and will invite her to phone the physician's office to obtain an appointment for Pap testing.

Primary outcomes

• uptake of screening invitation [18 months]

Secondary outcomes

• Cervical Intraepithelial Neoplasia (CIN) 3 identified [18 months]

Sex: Female, ages: 35 Years to 69 Years

Inclusion Criteria:

* members of consenting family physicians identified through OSCAR EMR
* overdue for Pap smear testing
* have not presented for Pap smear screening after 1 reminder letter

Exclusion Criteria:

* currently attending colposcopy clinic
* institutionalized
* without a cervix

• Alice Lytwyn, MD, FRCPC, Principal investigator, McMaster University