Prospective Comparison of Sleeve Gastrectomy Outcomes With Different Stapling Devices
| Registry | NCT02731079 |
|---|---|
| Status | Terminated - Study expired before any data was analyzed. |
| Phase | Not applicable |
| Study type | Interventional; randomized, parallel, masking: single, treatment |
| Enrollment | 62 (Actual) |
| Sponsor | Edna Rath (Fed) |
| Conditions | Morbid Obesity |
| Interventions | Covidien iDrive, Ethicon Echilon (Device) |
| Dates | start 2018-01-22, primary completion 2020-12-22, completion 2020-12-22, first posted 2016-04-07, last updated 2026-01-12 |
| Locations | 1 site in United States |
Related Papers Related Patents Related Grants Related Experts
All trials for Morbid Obesity All trials of Covidien iDrive All trials of Ethicon Echilon
Sleeve gastrectomy is now the most commonly performed bariatric surgery. While many studies have evaluated factors that may minimize post-operative hemorrhage and staple-line leak, the investigators are unaware of any studies that compare outcomes between devices from the two main stapler manufacturers used in this surgery, Covidien and Ethicon. The purpose of this study is to compare intraoperative characteristics, such as time to create sleeve, intraoperative bleeding, and time needed to load each cartridge, and post-operative characteristics, such as any complication requiring readmission (leak or hemorrhage), further surgical intervention, and weight loss, between patients who underwent sleeve gastrectomy with Covidien devices and Ethicon devices. Currently the investigators predominantly use whatever device is cheaper, but cost should not be the primary decisive factor if one device is superior to the other. If one device has better clinical outcomes, it should be the preferred device regardless of cost. If neither proves superiority, the investigators can justify using cost to determine which device to use in patient care.
New bariatric patients who have elected for a sleeve gastrectomy as part of standard of care will be invited to participate in the study during the bariatric clinic at William Beaumont Army Medical Center. Patients who meet the inclusion criteria will be invited to participate in the study. These patients will be consented in the bariatric clinic by a research coordinator (Doreen Bandari-Spaulding) or physician listed on the study if the coordinator is unavailable.
Three folders will be made, one for each bariatric surgeon, and 25 Covidien cards and 25 Ethicon cards will be placed into each for a total of 150 patients. All bariatric surgeons are trained and familiar with both devices. Once consented, a card will be removed at random to determine which stapler will be used. Bioabsorbable staple line reinforcement will be utilized with both staplers. Once in the operating room, the case start time, time from first staple firing to completion of sleeve, total stapler loads required, number of staple misfires, character of any staple line bleeding, and time for tech to load each cartridge will be recorded on a data collection sheet by a research resident, listed as an associative investigator on this protocol. The subject's post-operative course will follow the bariatric protocol. During follow-up, they will be monitored for weight loss, post-operative complications, and any other required interventions. This information will be obtained by reviewing the subject's medical record after follow-up appointments. Per the institutional bariatric protocol, subjects will follow-up at 3 weeks, 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, and annually. If a subject withdraws consent for the study prior to surgery, they will still receive surgery and perioperative treatment in line with institutional protocol, and they will be withdrawn and create a vacancy for a new subject. If a subject withdraws consent after surgery, data collection will cease for that subject. The investigators will clarify whether they want all data to be removed from the study or if they simply want no more data to be entered into the study and abide by their wishes, and they will remain in the original randomized group in accordance with intention-to-treat principles.
| Arm | Type | Interventions | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| Covidien | Active comparator | Device: Covidien iDrive | Group that will have sleeve gastrectomy performed using the Covidien iDrive powered stapler with absorbable polymer membrane staple line reinforcement. |
| Ethicon | Active comparator | Device: Ethicon Echilon | Group that will have sleeve gastrectomy performed using the Ethicon Echilon powered stapler with absorbable polymer membrane staple line reinforcement. |
Sex: All, ages: 18 Years to any
Inclusion Criteria: 1. Informed consent obtained and signed from each subject 2. Age ≥ 18 years 3. Requirement for agreement to avoid conception 4. BMI >40 5. BMI >35 with obesity-related co-morbidity 6. Pre-operative psychiatric evaluation 7. Pre-operative laboratory studies that fail to demonstrate secondary cause of obesity 8. Full course of triple therapy for patients with Helicobacter pylori on upper endoscopy Exclusion Criteria: 1. Pregnancy- Patients are not eligible for bariatric surgery, and if they become pregnant after surgery, they would present confounding variables and alter weight loss 2. Tobacco use within one month of surgery or any time within study period- Most staff will not perform bariatric surgery on active smokers as it negatively impacts healing 3. Prior bariatric surgery- Makes repeat bariatric surgery more difficult and could increase risk of complications 4. Inflammatory bowel disease- Rare diagnosis that may increase chance of complications, thus confounding results 5. Active duty military- Not eligible for bariatric surgery
| Milestone | Covidien | Ethicon |
|---|---|---|
| Started | 30 | 32 |
| Completed | 30 | 32 |
| Not completed | 0 | 0 |
Time frame: 1 year
| Arm | Deaths | Serious adverse events | Other adverse events |
|---|---|---|---|
| Covidien | 0/30 (0.0%) | 0/30 (0.0%) | 0/30 (0.0%) |
| Ethicon | 0/32 (0.0%) | 0/32 (0.0%) | 0/32 (0.0%) |
| Facility | City | Country | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| William Beaumont Army Medical Center | El Paso, Texas | United States |